Saturday, October 27, 2007

1905 World Series

The reign of terror is over! The Boston Americans are no longer the champions! But will the New York Giants be able to get revenge by beating the Philadelphia Athletics, or will the A's prove that the AL is in fact superior? It's the two greatest managers of all time - John McGraw vs. Connie Mack - in this 1905 throwdown!

NOTE: In the real series, the Philadelphia Athletics scored only 3 runs, all of them unearned.

REAL SERIES SCORE - Giants 4, Athletics 1
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1905_World_Series

I'll be going by present-day hosting format.

GAME 1
at Philadelphia

Joe McGinnity (NYG)
Eddie Plank (PHI)

Athletics 4, Giants 3

HR: none

W - Eddie Plank
L - Joe McGinnity

Player of the Game - Eddie Plank (W, CG)

GAME 2
at Philadelphia

Christy Mathewson (NYG)
Rube Waddell (PHI)

Athletics 4, Giants 3

HR: Socks Seybold (PHI)

W - Rube Waddell
L - Christy Mathewson

Player of the Game - Rube Waddell (W, CG)

GAME 3
at New York

Andy Coakley (PHI)
Red Ames (NYG)

Giants 11, Athetics 3

HR: none

W - Red Ames
L - Andy Coakley

Player of the Game - Red Ames (W, CG)

GAME 4
at New York

Chief Bender (PHI)
Dummy Taylor (NYG)

Giants 4, Athletics 3 (Isn't this getting a little annoying?)

HR: none

W - Dummy Taylor
L - Chief Benger
S - Joe McGinnity

Player of the Game - Dan McGann (3 RBI)

GAME 5
at New York

Weldon Henley (PHI)
Hooks Wiltse (NYG)

Athletics 12, Giants 0

HR: Harry Davis (PHI), Socks Seybold (PHI)

W - Weldon Henley
L - Hooks Wiltse

Player of the Game - Weldon Henley (W, CG, 4 H, shutout)

GAME 6
at Philadelphia

Joe McGinnity (NYG)
Eddie Plank (PHI)

Athletics 7, Giants 3

HR: none

W - Eddie Plank
L - Joe McGinnity

Player of the Game - Eddie Plank (W, CG)

ATHLETICS WIN SERIES, 4-2
Series MVP - Eddie Plank (2-0, 2 CG)

AL 3, NL 0. Not the way many historians planned it to go. At this point in real life, it was AL 1, NL 1. The pure dominance of Eddie Plank (PHI) has earned him MVP honors. He went 2-0 and got 2 complete games. Not very many pitchers get 2 complete games all season these days. However, second place surely belongs to Socks Seybold (PHI) for becoming the first player in World Series history to hit 2 home runs in a series.
NEXT TIME ON WORLD SERIES REDO - The Chicago Cubs take on the Chicago White Sox in a "Subway Series" of sorts! Don't miss out on the chance to see if the AL really is superior!

1 comment:

Bruce Henley said...

My grandfather was Weldon Henley, thanks for the shut out win with MVP honors. Bruce Henley, Grayson Ga.